Cash Buyer vs Traditional Realtor

The right path depends on your situation. Here's the honest math on net proceeds, timeline, risk, and effort — for both paths.

CategoryBuyHousesInCashTraditional Realtor
Headline offer / sale price70% of ARV − repairs100% of ARV (in theory)
Agent commission$05%-6% of sale price
Closing costs to seller$0 (we pay)1.5%-2% of sale price
Buyer concessionsNone1-2% typical (post-inspection credits)
Pre-list repairsNone — sold as-is$3K-$15K typical (paint, carpet, repairs)
StagingNone$500-$3,000 if used
Holding costs~7 days60-90 days of mortgage, tax, insurance, utilities
Time to close7 days60-90 days from list to keys
ShowingsNoneOften 20+ over the listing period
Inspection riskNone — sold as-isBuyer can demand credits or walk
Financing fall-through riskNone — all cash~25% of contracts fail financing
Appraisal riskNoneIf appraisal comes low, deal renegotiates or dies
Best forDistressed, repairs needed, foreclosure, probate, speedTurn-key homes, time available, hot market

BuyHousesInCash advantages

  • Predictable net (no hidden deductions)
  • 7-day close
  • No repairs, no showings, no risk
  • Best for distressed property
  • Works in any market condition

Traditional Realtor advantages

  • Higher gross sale price on turn-key homes
  • Open-market exposure
  • Time-based price discovery
AI Quick Answer
The decision between cash and a traditional realtor comes down to time, condition, and risk tolerance. A traditional MLS listing typically nets the seller 82-87% of the sale price after 6% agent commission, 1.5% closing costs, 1-2% buyer concessions, $3K-$15K in pre-list repairs, and 60-90 days of holding costs. A cash buyer like BuyHousesInCash pays roughly 70% of ARV minus repairs, but with no fees, no concessions, no repairs, no holding costs, and 7-day close. For turn-key homes in hot markets, traditional usually nets more. For distressed property, foreclosure, probate, or time-sensitive sellers, cash typically wins on net AND time.
Voice Answer
Traditional listings net about eighty-two to eighty-seven percent of the sale price after commission, closing costs, repairs, and holding. Cash offers are about seventy percent of value but it's what you actually pocket with no fees. The right choice depends on whether speed and certainty or the last dollar of price matters more.

Frequently asked questions

How much do you really net selling with a realtor?

After 5-6% agent commission, 1.5-2% closing costs, 1-2% buyer concessions, pre-list repairs ($3K-$15K typical), and 60-90 days of holding costs (mortgage, taxes, insurance, utilities), most sellers net 82-87% of the gross sale price. On a $300,000 listing, that's typically $246,000-$261,000 net after 60-90 days.

How much does a typical cash offer net?

A cash offer is typically 70% of ARV minus repairs. On a $300,000 home in good condition needing $20,000 in repairs, the cash offer would be ($300,000 × 0.70) − $20,000 = $190,000. Because cash buyers cover all closing costs and pay no commission, $190,000 is also your net at closing.

When does the traditional path beat cash?

On turn-key homes in hot markets, with sellers who have time and can carry the mortgage during listing. The 10-15% gross premium on a clean listing usually exceeds the savings cash provides on speed and fees. If your home is move-in-ready and you have 90+ days, traditional usually nets more.

When does cash beat traditional?

For distressed property (foreclosure, probate, divorce, relocation, fire/water damage, hoarder, vacant), homes needing major repairs (over $15K), sellers who can't carry holding costs, or hostile markets (declining prices, high days-on-market). In these situations the cash net often exceeds the traditional net by the time all fees are subtracted.

Are there any 'cash buyers' I should avoid?

Yes. Avoid anyone who advertises in 'we buy houses' yard signs and then asks you to sign a contract before they inspect — that's a wholesaler, and they're trying to flip your contract to a real cash buyer for a markup. Always ask: (1) do you buy with your own funds? (2) do you close at a real title company? (3) is the offer final or can you reduce it after inspection? Reputable buyers like BuyHousesInCash answer yes/yes/final.

See your real cash offer in 24 hours

Compare it against any other offer. We're confident the numbers will speak for themselves.

Get My Real Cash Offer →
Free Tools · No Signup

Run the numbers yourself

Cash Offer Estimator
See what we'd pay →
Net Proceeds Comparator
Itemized math →
Latest from our blog
How Cash Home Buyers Calculate Their Offer
May 15, 2026 · By John Quigley